What should be included in a performance review form? A performance review form is the written record of one review period for one person, and it should hold only what the review decision needs: a header (name, role, level, period, reviewer and date), the goals agreed at the start of the period and what happened to each, short evidence notes on the work delivered, the skills and behaviours expected at that level, a brief self-assessment, one rating on a scale everyone has seen, the reason for that rating, development objectives with the support promised, and next steps with sign-off. Anything the decision does not use, such as personality labels, health details or blank boxes nobody reads, should come out. A good test for each field is simple: if you deleted it, would the rating, the conversation or a later challenge be any worse?
Key takeaways
- Nine sections are enough. Header, goals, evidence, skills and behaviours, self-assessment, rating, rationale, development and next steps cover what a fair decision and a later appeal need.
- Structure the form around evidence, not impressions. Scullen, Mount and Goff (2000) found that the rater’s own tendencies explained 62% and 53% of the variance in ratings across two large samples, against 21% and 25% for the person’s actual performance.
- Use the self-assessment to open the conversation, not to set the rating. A meta-analysis by Harris and Schaubroeck (1988) put the corrected correlation between self and supervisor ratings at only .35.
- Write prompts about the work, not the person. Kluger and DeNisi (1996) found that more than a third of feedback interventions lowered performance, and that feedback worked less well the more it drew attention to the self.
- Collect less, label opinions. The ICO’s data minimisation guidance asks for data that is adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary, and says recorded opinions should be clearly marked as opinion, with the date and the author’s name and position.
The nine sections of a performance review form
Acas describes a performance review as a chance to discuss what someone is doing well, any areas for improvement, whether they need more support or training, and their career and development objectives. It also says the discussion should be written down and the record shared with the employee afterwards (Acas, 2026). The table below turns that into fields, and adds the parts that make a rating defensible in calibration.
| Section | What it records | Who completes it | Why it earns its place |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Header | Name, role, level, review period, reviewer, date | HR, pre-filled | Judges the person against the bar for their level and dates the opinion |
| 2. Goals and results | Each goal set at the start of the period, the measure, and what happened | Manager, with the employee | Ties the review to what was actually agreed, not to what is remembered |
| 3. Evidence notes | One line per point: the piece of work and what changed because of it | Manager | Gives calibration something another manager can check |
| 4. Skills and behaviours | Short statements for the role and level, each answered with an example | Manager | Covers how the work was done, which goals alone miss |
| 5. Self-assessment | Three or four short prompts: proudest work, what got in the way, what support would help | Employee, before the meeting | Surfaces work the manager missed and frames the conversation |
| 6. Rating | One grade on a scale with written definitions | Manager, then calibration | Lets ratings be compared across teams |
| 7. Rationale | Two or three sentences linking the grade to the evidence | Manager | The part an appeal or data request will be read against |
| 8. Development | One or two growth objectives and the support or training promised | Manager and employee | Makes the support commitment visible and checkable next time |
| 9. Next steps and sign-off | Next check-in date, employee comments, both names and dates | Both | Closes the record and gives the employee a place to disagree |
The performance review template with worked examples puts most of these sections into a scorecard you can copy, and the UK staff appraisal template covers the same ground in appraisal language for teams that prefer that wording. For the rating section, choose and define the levels before the cycle opens with the guide to employee performance rating scales.
What the research says about form design
A rating says a lot about the rater. Scullen, Mount and Goff analysed developmental ratings for two samples of managers (2,350 and 2,142 people), each rated by seven raters. Idiosyncratic rater effects accounted for 62% and 53% of the variance in ratings; the person’s general and dimension-level performance together accounted for 21% and 25% (Journal of Applied Psychology, 2000). The study used developmental multi-rater data rather than pay-linked reviews, so treat the numbers as a warning, not a forecast for your company. The design lesson still holds: a form that asks for a grade with no evidence beside it mostly records the manager’s habits. Evidence lines and a written rationale give calibration something to test, and the performance review bias guide covers the other checks worth building in.
Self-ratings and manager ratings often disagree. Harris and Schaubroeck’s meta-analysis in Personnel Psychology (1988) found a corrected correlation of .35 between self and supervisor ratings, compared with .62 between peer and supervisor ratings. That is not a reason to drop the self-assessment. It is a reason to keep it short, ask about examples rather than a self-score, and treat the gap as the start of the conversation rather than a number to average.
Specific goals beat vague ones. Locke and Latham’s review of 35 years of goal-setting research in American Psychologist (2002) reports that specific, difficult goals consistently led to higher performance than an instruction to “do your best”. A goals section that records only a goal title invites “do your best” in disguise. Give each goal a measure and a date when it is set, and the review form simply carries them forward. The goal-setting guide shows how to write them.
Feedback about the person can backfire. Kluger and DeNisi’s meta-analysis of 607 effect sizes found that feedback interventions improved performance on average, but more than a third of them reduced it, and effectiveness fell as feedback moved attention away from the task and towards the self (Psychological Bulletin, 1996). On a form, that argues for prompts such as “What work had the most impact, and why?” over “How would you describe this person’s attitude?”.
Data protection shapes the form too. The ICO’s guidance on the data minimisation principle (Article 5(1)(c) UK GDPR; the ICO notes the page is under review after the Data (Use and Access) Act) says personal data should be adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary, and that you must not collect it on the off-chance it might be useful. It also says a recorded opinion should be clearly marked as opinion, carry the date and the author’s name and position, and, where it will have a significant impact, state the evidence it rests on. That is a good description of a review form’s header, rating and rationale. The same principle applies under the EU GDPR in Ireland.
What to leave out
- Personality labels. “Positive attitude” or “not a team player” describe the person, not the work, and are hard to evidence. Replace them with behaviours you can point to.
- Pay and salary fields. Keep pay recommendations in a separate step with tighter access, so the review conversation is about performance and fewer people see salary data.
- Health, absence reasons and personal circumstances. If they are relevant to support or adjustments, handle them through the right process, not a free-text box on a widely shared form.
- Unprompted free-text boxes. “Any other comments?” produces long, uneven answers. Ask a specific question or delete the box.
- Questions nobody uses. If no one reads a section in calibration or in the next 1:1, it is admin time and extra personal data with no purpose.
- Mid-cycle edits. Everyone in one cycle should be reviewed on the same version of the form.
Why forms drift at 100 to 1,500 people
In a 40-person company the founder knows every form. Between roughly 100 and 1,500 staff the form becomes a shared document that many hands change, and the same problems tend to appear:
- Every department edits its own copy. Engineering adds a technical section, Sales adds targets, and by year-end there are six versions. Ratings stop being comparable, which is the whole point of performance calibration.
- The form grows every cycle. Each complaint adds a question and nothing is ever removed. Managers respond by writing less in every box, so the evidence gets thinner as the form gets longer.
- Goals live somewhere else. Goals set in January in one place are scored in December from memory in another, so section 2 is rebuilt by hand each time.
- Managers are new to writing reviews. A second layer of first-time managers arrives, and the form is their only guide. The review prep checklist for managers and the performance review examples help them write evidence instead of adjectives.
Our perspective
When a People lead sends me their review form, I look at the last two boxes first. If the rationale box is optional and the development box is free text, I can usually predict the calibration meeting: long, opinion-led, and settled by whoever speaks most confidently. The middle of the form rarely causes the trouble; the bits that should connect the rating to the evidence and the evidence to next quarter usually do.
My advice is to make the form shorter and stricter at the same time. Fewer sections, but each one required, each one tied to something checkable, and each one used by someone after the meeting. If you cannot name who reads a field and when, take it out. A form that a manager can complete well in one sitting beats a thorough one that is completed badly at midnight before the deadline.
— Ash Taherian, Product Sales Executive, Revolut People
Where Revolut People fits, and where it doesn’t
Read this section knowing I work at Revolut People. In Revolut People, the review is a scorecard on the employee’s record, next to their goals, 1:1 notes and feedback, so sections 2, 3 and 8 do not need to be copied in by hand. Skills sit in a central Skill Bank that is reused across roles and across performance and hiring scorecards, which helps keep one version of the form across departments. Access is set by permission group, and the security and access one-pager explains how the default permission groups split personal, performance and salary data, and how retention periods are set per location. You can see a review and calibration in the short films on the product tour.
The limits are real. Software will not decide what belongs on your form; you still need to agree the sections, the rating definitions and who signs off. The Performance plan has a public list price from £10 per employee per month, billed annually, with a minimum annual spend of £5,000 in the UK and EEA (see the pricing estimator), so a small company with one cycle a year is often better served by a well-designed template. And if your HRIS already holds a review form your managers use well, fixing the form there may be enough.
If you would like a second pair of eyes on your current form, book a 15-minute review and bring it with you. I will tell you which sections to cut, even if you keep your current tool.
Step plan: rebuild your form in four weeks
- Week 1: audit the current form. List every field. For each, write who reads it and when. Mark anything with no reader for removal.
- Week 1: check the data. With your data protection lead, confirm each field is needed for the review purpose, remove sensitive data that has no place on the form, and agree how long completed forms are kept.
- Week 2: map to the nine sections. Use the table above. Make the rating, rationale and next-steps sections required. Define every rating level in writing.
- Week 2: rewrite the prompts. Turn trait questions into questions about work and behaviour. Check wording with the performance review bias checker.
- Week 3: test with two managers. Ask each to complete the form for one real report from last cycle. Time it, and note where they wrote nothing or wrote adjectives.
- Week 4: lock the version and brief managers. Publish one form for the whole cycle, with a filled-in example, and run it alongside the performance review checklist for HR managers.
Not sure where your current process is weakest? The two-minute performance health check scores standards, goal alignment, bias and admin burden.
Bottom line
A performance review form should record the goals, the evidence, the expected skills and behaviours, a short self-assessment, one defined rating with its reason, development commitments and signed next steps, and very little else. Research on rater effects, self-ratings, goal setting and feedback all points the same way: structure the form around checkable evidence about the work, not impressions of the person. Keep one version per cycle, make the rationale required, and remove any field nobody uses.
FAQ
How do you prepare for a performance review as a manager?
Re-read the goals agreed at the start of the period, gather evidence from the whole period rather than the last month, read the employee’s self-assessment, draft the rating and rationale, and pick one or two development points. The review prep checklist sets this out step by step.
Should employees complete a self-assessment before a performance review?
Yes, if it is short. Three or four prompts about their most important work, obstacles and the support they need help the manager see work they missed. Use it to open the conversation rather than as a second rating, because self and manager ratings often differ.
What questions should a manager ask in a performance review?
Ask about outcomes, obstacles, support and next steps: what went well and why, what got in the way, what would help, and what the person wants to work on next. The post on manager performance review questions lists questions by stage of the meeting.
Do you have to use a written performance review form in the UK?
No law sets out a mandatory review form. Acas guidance says employers should review employees’ performance regularly, ideally at least once a year, and that it is important to keep a written record of what is discussed and share it with the employee. A consistent form is the simplest way to do that, and it helps if a rating is later challenged. This is general information, not legal advice.
Sources
- Acas: Reviews and appraisals - Performance management (last updated 23 June 2026) - what reviews cover; keep a written record and share it with the employee; review at least once a year
- Acas: Appraisal form templates (accessed 19 November 2026) - free forms based on job objectives, self-appraisal and scheme review
- Steven E. Scullen, Michael K. Mount and Maynard Goff: Understanding the latent structure of job performance ratings, Journal of Applied Psychology 85(6), 956-970 (2000) - idiosyncratic rater effects 62% and 53% of rating variance; ratee performance 21% and 25%
- Michael M. Harris and John Schaubroeck: A meta-analysis of self-supervisor, self-peer, and peer-supervisor ratings, Personnel Psychology 41(1), 43-62 (1988) - self-supervisor .35; peer-supervisor .62
- Edwin A. Locke and Gary P. Latham: Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation, American Psychologist 57(9), 705-717 (2002) - specific, difficult goals outperform “do your best”
- Avraham N. Kluger and Angelo DeNisi: The effects of feedback interventions on performance, Psychological Bulletin 119(2), 254-284 (1996) - 607 effect sizes; over a third of feedback interventions decreased performance
- Information Commissioner’s Office: Principle (c): Data minimisation (accessed 19 November 2026; under review after the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025) - adequate, relevant and limited; label opinions with date and author